Beer and Pavement


Posted in Records by SM on September 23, 2011

Twenty years ago tomorrow, music changed for me and changed me. September 24, 1991 was the day Geffen released Nirvana’s Nevermind, widely considered a game-changing album throughout the record industry. It changed even more than that.

Well, honestly, it didn’t change me on that exact date, 20 years ago. The shift came some time after, whenever “Smells Like Teen Spirit” entered my zone of awareness. I searched out the track and decided it was worthy a purchase. I can’t remember who actually paid for the cassette, but my brother and I exchanged it back and forth as we played the hell out of it.

By now, the story of Nevermind is well-known. It bumped Michael Jackson and/or several hair metal bands from their perch atop the Billboard charts. It set off a signing frenzy of bands from Seattle. Grunge became a household term to describe anything in flannel, combat boots, and full of feedback. It ignited a cultural revolution – which may have only been superficial, but a movement nonetheless.

For me, it opened up a whole new world. There was the introduction to an underground I had no idea existed. It validated my disgust for the mainstream. And it gave new voice to my burgeoning political views. It did all this and then some.

Nirvana was one of the first (and maybe only) true indie bands to completely blow up. Their previous record, Bleach, sold a few thousand copies and sounded nothing like a band ready to take the world by storm. I love some tracks from that record, but I never heard anything on Bleach that made me think Nevermind was possible – and this was in retrospect.

The band was originally signed to Sub Pop. In fact, Nevermind featured Sub Pop’s logo, indicating that the label would pay its bills with Nirvana money for years to come. The Sub Pop narrative became an obsession of mine. My uncle was school chums with Jonathan Poneman, co-founder of the label. My uncle developed a substance addiction and Poneman developed bands. The rest was history. Still, I felt some sort of connection to the label and even the band that went beyond mere fandom.

Nirvana started getting press and at every turn, Kurt Cobain was championing some great band. Off the top of my head, I can think of Meat Puppets, Sonic Youth, Dinosaur Jr, The Breeders, Beat Happening, Bikini Kill, etc. that came into my collection mainly due to Cobain’s insistence that his fans listen to other bands besides his own. And each of those new bands lead me to an infinite number of bands I won’t list here (not to mention all the great bands on Sub Pop over the years).

The funny part about Nirvana and Nevermind‘s influence over my music tastes is that this record wasn’t that great. Sure, it’s a nice collection of good songs. However, it’s a clear ripoff of The Pixies’ loud-quiet-loud dynamic. Someone had finally put to tape a collection that properly nodded to the underground and then spruced it up with a remix. It’s a slick-sounding record which sort of betrays what Nirvana was about. Lucky for us, MTV still showed music videos and live performances at that time to help us see what Nirvana was all about. Still, I’d have to say that In Utero was a stronger album and represented a truer version of Nirvana, but it didn’t have the impact Nevermind had.

Either way, the aesthetic and message of that album, Cobain’s championing of the underground, and my new obsession with Sub Pop and the Pacific Northwest pushed me into what is turning out to be a lifelong pursuit of independent rock, aka indie rock. Sure, Pavement is my favorite band of all-time, but Nirvana was my first true love.

Cobain not only used Nevermind as a way to promote the music he loved, but it was also the thing that vaulted him in the public eye in a way that made him the spokesperson of our generation. Fair or not, Kurt Cobain spoke to and sometimes for all of us. And the things of which he spoke were important. He was notorious for testing gender lines and the status quo. My eventual path down progressivism was initially guided by Cobain’s own political and social views. There are pieces of that in Nevermind. I found them while listening and re-listening in vain attempts to decipher Cobain’s screams.

It’s easy for someone to discount Nevermind‘s importance to society. I mean, it basically rehashed the previous 20 years of punk in one fell swoop. So, very little new ground was ever covered within its grooves. One might even point out that the record industry looks very much the same despite Nirvana’s success.

Still, it was the first wildly successful record that sounded the way indie bands did in those days. Nevermind‘s release was the culmination of decades of punk, hardcore, and indie breaking through a wall put up by major labels and corporate radio. That had as much to do with its big sound as anything. And the lasting effect is that indie artists actually share space on industry sales lists with major label releases. They command the same venues and often outlast their corporate cousins. I’m not sure indie music is as strong without Nevermind‘s success, even if it wasn’t an indie release itself.

And what about the music?

Maybe some of the most famous guitar licks to open an album ever happen at the beginning of “Smells Like Teen Spirit.” The best part of the song is that insults the mainstream kids who flocked to stores to buy Nirvana’s major label debut. It was an inside joke with legendary riot grrrl Kathleen Hanna. It’s the song that signified everything was changing. Maybe that change was fashionable or superficial for some, but whatever it was happened as this song first hit the airwaves.

The second track was the fourth single off the record. Interestingly, “In Bloom” was considered for Bleach, but I think most would agree that it fits with Nevermind‘s anti-mainstream theme. I don’t know whether it was prophetic or not, but the song came out as a single at the right time as sort of retort to all the d-bags and jocks who were adopting Nirvana as their own.

“Come As You Are” was the second single and, quite honestly, was more hit-worthy than “Smells Like Teen Spirit.” The only thing it lacked was the punch the first track contained. Still, a hit is a hit. Sadly, it’s clichéd to say, but this song was ironically accurate with its now infamous gun lyric.

“Breed” brought it in a way that Bleach-era Nirvana did. This song reeked of angst and alienation. Plus, it never hurt to attract young males with aggression and some heavy guitars.

The third single was “Lithium,” a song I think would have felt at home on In Utero, Nirvana’s best album. Teenage angst and male awkwardness comes through loud and clear. The loud-quiet-loud dynamic is certainly apparent. This is maybe Nevermind‘s best track.

Where do I begin with “Polly?” As the story goes, some assholes sang the song while raping a woman. Cobain was disgusted by the entire episode and made sure to call out the perpetrators in the liner notes for Nirvana’s rarities release, Incesticide. Aesthetically, it didn’t fit with Bleach and found itself on Nevermind. We all ate up that grunge performed acoustically thing. (see: MTV Unplugged)

Fuck, man. Rocking out to “Territorial Pissings” was what it was all about. And was he saying “gotta find a way, a better way” or was it “gotta find a way, I better wait?” Does it matter?

A perfect B-side for “Smells Like Teen Spirit” was “Drain You.” This is maybe the lone love song of Nevermind. Following “Drain You” is the fantastic “Lounge Act” with its obtuse drug references. “Stay Away” was what every teen-age boy questioning everything thought all the time. “On a Plain” is one of the best songs any band has ever snuck into a next-to last slot.

“Something in the Way” is an eerie and depressing way to close the record. However, it hints at the subtlety Cobain longed to fit into his repertoire, getting away from the aggression of grunge and moving beyond Nevermind‘s pure aggression into something more complex.

I could write about the hidden track (“Endless, Nameless”), but it was hidden for a reason…

Nevermind was an important record for many reasons. This is the first time I’ve seen the reason to celebrate something that’s 20 years old. This album represented a movement, even a generation. I remember feeling a ton of dissatisfaction with the world and Nevermind captured that. In fact, I’d argue that Nevermind is still meaningful to our current condition. Generation X has been through a lot and Nevermind was there for all of it.

I was lucky enough to see Nirvana during their In Utero tour. They were probably the last huge band I could ever love. Nevermind was the beginning and the last two decades of searching for the thrill Nevermind gave me since has made for a fun ride through indie rock. Happy birthday, Nevermind.

Tagged with: ,

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. jeffmenter said, on September 23, 2011 at 9:59 am

    I was tempted to write something snarky but you’ve crafted a compelling and heartfelt post so I won’t go that route. I’ll be more straightforward: here are my memories of the album and how it affected me.

    When Nevermind came out, I was 18 or so, living in Idaho, and had been playing in bands for many years. This included concert and marching bands in high school as well as rock/punk/cover bands in my non-school time. But what really piqued my interest musically was playing in the jazz band and learning about improvisation within a jazz/blues context.

    I hung out with a more punk/skater crowd (though I didn’t really self-identify as such, they were just more fun to hang out with) so I got exposed to lots of different music like Nirvana, Sex Pistols, Misfits, Bad Religion, etc. I also went to shows in Boise and saw smaller bands like Warlock Pinchers, Screaming Trees, Social Distortion, etc.

    I didn’t really identify with the energy of the bands and I wasn’t really into appreciating songwriting that much. It’s more like I got a massive hard-on for musicians that had skills that showed either great technical ability or had a unique and compelling improvisational voice.

    So when Nirvana and the whole grunge scene blew up my reaction was pretty much (to the extent that I noticed the explosion at all), well, kinda “meh.” They really didn’t have anything to offer me at the time and I didn’t understand why they were so popular. They didn’t appear to have any exceptional musical skill and seemed to be just tapping into the lucrative teen angst demographic. (I didn’t have much patience for teen angst even when I was a teen.)

    Since I’ve gotten older and have become more interested in the craft of songwriting I think I can appreciate Nirvana more. Kurt wrote some pretty melodic, almost poppy songs that aren’t half bad. And without Nirvana I probably never would have found out about the beautiful joys of listening to the Meat Puppets.

    Anyway, this is already longer than I intended. I don’t really know what my point is. I know we’ve talked about this kind of thing before but this may give you a little more insight into why I’m a snarky asshole sometimes. I can definitely be an annoying music elitist but I really shouldn’t be because there’s always going to be someone more elitist than me and music is and should be for everyone.

    • builderofcoalitions said, on September 23, 2011 at 11:08 am

      I think what is too bad about Nirvana is that sometimes the aesthetic overtook the songcraft. Many liked the aesthetic. People like yourself hated it. It seemed to celebrate noise over music. This can be good or bad. At the time, music was either super-clean and poppy or all masturbatory in the form of hair metal. However, what people missed was the craftsmanship Cobain put into his songwriting.

      I think this is why Nevermind has had so much staying power over the years. You’re right. He wrote some pretty amazing melodies. His songwriting was more a product of the Beatles than the Sex Pistols. Sadly, few paid much attention to these attributes. The music was either dismissed or thoughtlessly embraced.

      I can appreciate your take on the music. The aesthetic doesn’t appeal to you, but the songcraft does. It’s interesting that you’ve discovered this aspect of Cobain’s music after you shed the impulses of youth…

      Which brings me to your teen angst bit. I get not having time for teen angst, but I wasn’t as fortunate to hang out with punks and skaters growing up. The people I went to school with thought this was as good as it gets. Many did not go to college nor did they leave. They lived a charmed life. I thought this was all wrong and felt a lot of angst trying to fit in. You didn’t have to feel that angst as it sounds as though your friends were feeling enough for you. That and it’s just not in your personality. (I think I know you well enough to make this observation.) You’re in the minority. We’re a narcissistic lot and we’re at our most selfish when we’re 1-3 and 12-18. Teenage angst paid off well because it’s what a lot of us feel.

      I think I have now written too much and am not completely sure what I’m saying either.

  2. […] nostalgia cycle has firmly settled on my generation (X). There are numerous Nevermind tributes, including my own. However, there were other records that came out in 1991. That and a lot has come out in honor of […]

  3. beeronmyshirt said, on September 26, 2011 at 7:58 pm

    I think the B-side of Nevermind is one of the greatest B-sides ever. Those songs still just blow me away.

  4. […] is bit more difficult to judge based on this criteria. I recently wrote about the 20th anniversary of Nirvana’s Nevermind. That album changed the game for me. A whole new […]

  5. […] The Nevermind memorial parade – I too participated in this bit of nostalgia during Nevermind‘s 20th anniversary. While the merits of the album’s musical quality can be debated, it is hard to ignore the […]

Leave a Reply to builderofcoalitions Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: