Beer and Pavement

On Soul

Posted in Beer, Intersections, Manifesto by SM on November 18, 2011
Trappist Westvleteren 12

There's a whole lotta soul under those caps. - Click for source.

Some big news in the beer world this week was AB InBev’s announcement that they will be opening Belgium beer cafes, sort of akin to the influx of Irish pubs 20 years ago. For such stories, I like to depend human filters such as Stan Hieronymus at Appellation Beer Blog. Stan sorted through an article to find a key quote. One line caught my eye:

“You don’t build create a Belgian beer cafe in five minutes,” De Baets says. “It’s generations of owners and customers that build the place, and then give a soul to it.”

De Baets is Yvan De Baets, masterbrewer and co-owner of De la Senne brewery in Brussels. Stan sees De Baets as a trusted mind in the beer community. So, by proxy, I trust him as well.

Regardless, the part that really struck me was the fact that an authentic Belgian beer cafe has a soul. That’s the biggest difference between an actual Belgian beer cafe and whatever AB InBev will establish in every mall and airport across the country. The idea of the soul of a place (or things – that’s coming) speaks to me. It feels like the clear difference between the authentic and corporate is the soul.

How does a place or thing develop a soul? As suggested above, it’s the people who frequent a place. It’s experiences and memories that contribute to a soul. I suppose that’s not entirely different from people, but we tend to have souls to begin with (if you believe in that sort of thing). All the marketing in the world cannot construct a soul. If anything, the sterilized, watered-down, corporate aesthetic that is sure to pervade these AB InBev beer cafes will hardly leave room for a soul to develop.

Anything corporate tends to be soulless. Despite what Mitt Romney tells us, corporations are not people and they have no soul. Of course, an authentic Belgian beer cafe isn’t technically able to have a soul either, but try telling that to its loyal patrons. For anyone who has a regular place at which they socialize and imbibe, said place is a living, breathing thing. So, such a place can have a soul. It just takes a while to develop.

Before you all jump down my throat for discounting anything corporate, I’ll admit that these places and things can have a soul. It’s just more difficult in a corporate model. Apple products have a soul, even when some of their corporate actions are a bit soulless. Some of the old auto factories in Detroit certainly had souls as the center of their communities…until they were shut down and their jobs were sent south of the border. (I’m not talking about Ohio.) There are other examples, but I don’t think it’s nearly as prevalent as the non-corporate world.

Like the Belgian beer cafes, craft beer has a soul. It’s in the people who found breweries and brew the beer. It comes from the cicerones and beer enthusiasts. Homebrewers almost certainly play a role in the soul of craft beer as well. While corporate beer depends on its own people, hard-working, salt of the earth kinds of people, it’s not the same thing. Any semblance of a soul is sucked out corporate rice adjunct lagers when you find the Budweiser you get in St. Louis is exactly the same as the one you get in Hong Kong or Germany. Corporate efforts to standardize their product everywhere strips it of its humanity and its soul with it.

Craft beer demonstrates its soul through the characters who represent it. Although Boston Beer Co. has nearly outgrown its craft beer status, Jim Koch remains the face of Sam Adams beers and continues to fight for the company’s soul. Better examples might be found at Dogfish Head (Sam Calagione), Stone (Greg Koch), Russian River (Vinnie Cilurzo), Jolly Pumpkin (Ron Jeffries), Stillwater (Brian Strumke), etc. All these people are not only advocates for their industry, they are also personality that encapsulates their breweries. This personality and humanity gives these breweries soul.

Soul is how I separate what’s indie and what’s not. No, I’m not talking about that kind of soul, but it can fit my definition if need be. I’m talking about the same kind of soul that goes into craft beer. It’s that soul that can only be associated with humanity that defines indie rock. Can a band on a major label have soul? Sure. However, so many musicians are constructed or manipulated in a way that strips their art of any kind of soul.

Music, like all art, is tougher to pin down to what has soul and what doesn’t. It’s so much more subjective. Also, all art comes from a very human place, meaning that just about all of it demonstrates a soul at work. So, I won’t go much further into what constitutes soulful music and what doesn’t. I have a post on the way about what’s indie. That should suffice to define my criteria.

Anyway, the original point is that something that is indie, craft, artisanal, whatever demonstrates soul or soulfulness. The human component should be strong in order for that soul to exist. As producers grow and become more corporate, some of that humanity and consequently the soul is lost. So, the next time someone asks why you choose to drink that craft beer, tell them it’s because it has soul.

Tagged with: ,

15 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Jade said, on November 18, 2011 at 9:01 am

    I guarantee that these airport McPubs will not have a friendly bartender who makes suggestions and brings you samples like the one I encountered in an Amsterdam beer cafe. They will care more about turnover of asses on the barstools. It’s like the difference between McNally’s Irish Pub in CoMo (a frat bar with Irish junk on the walls) and Paddy Malone’s in Jefferson City, which is family-owned by Irish-Americans who obviously care about their repeat customers. I wish I could transplant it to Columbia so I would actually want to hang out there more.

    • Zac said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:07 am

      The BcPubs will be soulless. You nailed it.

  2. Lyrics, Libations, and Life said, on November 18, 2011 at 9:09 am

    Your writings have been rather reflective on beer and music this week. Just to clarify, are you saying the owners of Dogfish, Stone, etc… have lost the soul in their beer? I kind of think of them like those Indie bands that we don’t really consider all that indie anymore. Like Death Cab for Cutie were pioneers in the indie band movement. However, they also managed to blow up and get signed to a major record label. Therefore, you really wouldn’t call them indie anymore, but they were sort of integral to the movements success. That’s sort of how I see breweries like Dogfish, Stone, and even Boston Beer Co. They kind of started the movement, and they managed to show just how far you can take it, and they were inspirational to a lot of other breweries inception.

    • Zac said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:24 am

      No. What I was trying to say was that these characters add personality and a bit of humanity to their breweries. These things equate to the soul of their companies. Interestingly Jeff seemed to be confused by what I wrote as well. This may be cause for some revision, me thinks.

      I still think a lot of those bands (not all) are still indie. That will be tomorrow’s post.

      • jeffmenter said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:29 am

        I was only confused about which reply button to hit.

        Aside from outing yourself as a total Apple fanboi the post was spot on.

      • Zac said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:32 am

        Hello, Pot. My name is Kettle.

      • Lyrics, Libations, and Life said, on November 18, 2011 at 12:09 pm

        Ah, I see what you’re saying. Then I definitely agree with this concept. Ha

  3. jeffmenter said, on November 18, 2011 at 10:56 am

    I think that since Greg Koch has commented on this very blog we can consider Stone to be plenty soulful.

    • Zac said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:01 am

      I think that’s what I said in the post.

      • jeffmenter said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:28 am

        I meant that to be a reply to the post above from Lyrics, Libations, and Life. I hit the wrong reply button.

      • Zac said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:32 am

        That’s sort of what I thought, but I wanted to respond just in case… especially after your comment yesterday.

  4. Tash said, on November 18, 2011 at 11:09 pm

    Ohhh, Belgian Beer Cafes! We have a great one here in Melbourne (Australia), which oozes soul and spirit! Nothing like it on a bright sunny summers day in the city!.
    But you’re right, the Irish pub idea/virus has certainly made those types (apart from some old school ones) drab and character-less.
    Surely Belgian beer and it’s craft beer array will help to diversify…..not McDonalds-ify!

    • Zac said, on November 19, 2011 at 8:45 am

      Now, that’s Australian for beer!

  5. […] indie isn’t equal to being unknown or unsuccessful. It’s keeping that human, even soulful element that corporate acts just can’t duplicate in the music. The outcome might be […]

  6. […] raising my daughter, a lot of discovery is starting to escape my grasp. That’s where the soulfulness of things like craft beer and indie rock enrich my life a […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: